Italian restaurants

Tony's Italian Deli

4.8 268 reviews 11:00 AM - 05:00 PM 3360 Sheffield Ave, Dyer, IN 46311, United States

Discover this place

Tony's Italian Deli, located in Dyer, IN, is a gem for anyone seeking authentic Italian flavors. This welcoming deli boasts a menu filled with homemade delights, from scratch-made sausages to fresh pastas like stuffed shells and ravioli. Customers rave about the quality and freshness of each dish, with many noting the friendly atmosphere created by Tony and his dedicated staff.

One standout recommendation is the tomato focaccia, a must-try that transports guests back to authentic Italian sandwiches reminiscent of those found in Chicago. The deli’s commitment to cleanliness and customer satisfaction shines through in reviews, with patrons appreciating the thorough service and generous portions. Whether you’re picking up ingredients for a family meal or enjoying one of their acclaimed subs, the experience is designed to make you feel like part of the family.

With many returning for both the food and the warm service, Tony's Italian Deli has established itself as a beloved stop for deli lovers and Italian cuisine enthusiasts alike. You won’t leave empty-handed or unsatisfied!

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service
Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Quiet

Crowd

Family-friendly

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Tony's Italian Deli before visiting.

Reviews for Tony's Italian Deli

4.8

268 reviews

100%

Review highlights

Based on 268 reviews

Tony's Italian Deli in Dyer, IN, is widely praised for its authentic Italian offerings and exceptional freshness. Customers frequently highlight the deli’s clean and inviting atmosphere, complemented by attentive and accommodating service from the owner and staff. The menu showcases a blend of homemade scratch-made items and imported goods, including sausages, pasta, sauces, and a variety of deli meats, olives, and cheeses. Patrons appreciate the deli’s careful preparation and generous portions, with particular mention of standout items like sandwiches and baked goods. The combination of quality ingredients, friendly service, and a welcoming environment creates a reliable destination for both casual meals and take-home Italian specialties. Overall, Tony's Italian Deli is regarded as a top-notch Italian market that consistently delivers flavorful products and a pleasant shopping and dining experience.

tami nicksic

Jul 06, 2025

It was worth the trip from Porter county! We ate lunch and then made a haul of food to bring back home to serve up at a later date. Homemade, scratch sausages and frozen pasta stuffed shells , ravioli and his spaghetti sauces along with his Italian beef with AuJus to be enjoyed with our extended family at a later date!

Tahanna Tucker

Jun 12, 2025

I have not been to a deli that is so clean! First of all, Tony and his staff are amazing and very thorough. He’s precise and will work with you on anything! The amount of meat, olives, and cheese I purchased for my daughter’s charcuterie boxes for prom was reasonable and nothing short of fresh and flavorful! From service to food, everything was pleasant. I’ll be back!

amanda cruz

May 04, 2025

This Deli is top notch. I enjoyed a nice afternoon with my aunt and uncle. As soon as we walked in we were greeted by the owner. He truly was a kind man. My uncle and him hit it off right away. We tried both hot and cold sandwiches, pastas, fresh octopus and Greek olives. We also took some goodies home. Everything was FRESH and I don’t say that lightly. The place was very clean and well kept. Loved the deli meat is cut with each sandwich. I would recommend it to anyone and plan to come back soon! Thank you for a great meal and great service!

Corinna Maggi

May 03, 2025

Nice Italian deli with basic fresh options and lots of shelf and frozen options that are either imported or made from scratch. We bought items to make a sandwich and took it home and ate it right away. DO NOT PASS UP THE TOMATO FOCACCIA. It reminded me of some the excellent sandwiches I would get in Chicago. We will definitely buy one every single time we stop in. I was tempted to try one of their fresh desserts but at 5 each I couldn't pull the trigger. (Maybe I'm just ignorant to the going rate as I rarely buy fresh to go desserts.) But I'm sure they would have been delicious as they looked it! Owner (I'm assuming, or manager but definitely got the owner vibe) was super kind. We definitely come back to local places that treat you like family!

Nick Ventimiglia

Apr 17, 2025

I heard good things about this deli. I love Italian grocery stores. I got the wise guy sub and the canoli. It was great. Glad to see Illinois isn't the only place with good Italian markets. I did a review for my YouTube channel "Mailman Nick"

rick watwood

Apr 13, 2025

I have longed for an Italian beef sandwich that has that special Italian flavor and I got it at Tony's. Great food and very nice friendly help. Thank you my friend for a great meal for me and my wife. We loved it. Rick

Jessica K

Apr 12, 2025

Stopped in for sandwich and salad that were both fantastic. Had to try a cannoli which was being made right then. It was so yummy!!! Left with a jar of vodka sauce too that we can't wait to try. Great experience! Bring cash if you go because of extra fee for credit card!

Lesley Johnson

Mar 16, 2025

This deli doesn’t deserve anything less than 5 stars. This was our first time. Went with my husband and kids. The paninis were delicious. The bread was so fresh. The Caesar salad was amazing! Very reasonably priced. Will be back again.